Judgment's History

Each published version of JUDGMENT.md, what changed in it, and why.

JUDGMENT.md is meant to improve through use. Each change to it is made openly, with its reason on record, and this page lists every published version of the file, newest first.

Version 1.0, 25 October 2026

The first published version. It sets out what a judgment is for and who may run it, the stance a judgment takes, and how it treats evidence. It describes how a judgment is made, first by understanding the case and then by applying the Codex's own tests to it, and the checks a judgment passes before it goes out. It gives the form a judgment takes at a quick, a full and a deep reading, how the file stands to the Compact, and what besides JUDGMENT.md and COMPACT.md shapes a judgment. Its header carries this notice:

The first published version, in use by the Codex's caretakers and improved from that use. A judgment made with it can be wrong, and its full and deep readings have been tested less than its quick reading. Models sometimes add details to a person's story that the person never gave, so check what a judgment says about your own situation against what you told it.

Before its release, JUDGMENT.md was tested on many questions and with several models. The notice states the limits known from that testing. The caretakers released it with those limits stated, rather than holding it back until it performed without fault. Its next improvements come from use on the questions people actually bring, starting with the caretakers' own. The Amendment Log records its publication in the entry The Compact Applied to One Question: JUDGMENT.md 1.0.